New Zealand finished the first day of the opening Test against India at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on 19 November at 243 for 5 in 82 overs. Henry Nicholls is unbeaten on 113 and Glenn Phillips on 94. The pair added an unbroken 173 for the sixth wicket after India's pace attack had left the hosts at 70 for 5 in the morning. By stumps, though, the talk was less about the batting recovery and more about who was missing from India's team.

How the day unfolded

Shubman Gill won the toss and chose to bowl on a damp, grassy surface. Jasprit Bumrah made the early breakthroughs, removing Tom Latham and Daryl Mitchell in the morning session, and later Tom Blundell. According to the match reports, New Zealand were 60 for 4 at lunch and 70 for 5 soon after, with Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj each taking a wicket. Blundell's catch at first slip by Gill off Kamboj was the only wicket to fall after the interval.

Then the pitch and the weather eased. Reports say the ball went soft and the skies cleared, and Nicholls and Phillips began to score off almost every loose delivery. New Zealand added 80 runs in the second session for the loss of one wicket and more than 100 in the last session without losing any. Phillips reached his fifty with a cut off Bumrah in the 50th over. Nicholls completed his hundred in the 70th over with a single off Prasidh Krishna, his fifth Test century at this ground. He did so in only 15 innings at the venue, and in the absence of Kane Williamson he is batting at number three.

India also let a chance go. When Nicholls was on 102, a top-edged pull went up between Devdutt Padikkal and wicketkeeper Rishabh Pant, and neither completed the catch.

The bowling figures

Bumrah ended with 3 for 52 from 17 overs and was easily India's best bowler. Akash Deep took 1 for 33 and Kamboj 1 for 57. Prasidh Krishna conceded 58 runs in 16 overs without a wicket, and Washington Sundar went for 38 without a wicket. Nicholls said after play that Bumrah was swinging the ball both ways and that he expected "more of the same" on Friday morning.

The selection row

The loudest debate was about the playing eleven. India went in with four fast bowlers, Bumrah, Akash Deep, Kamboj and Prasidh, and left out Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja, with Washington Sundar picked as the spinner. Both reserves came on only as substitute fielders. The Hindu pointed out that Siraj, with 43 wickets in 11 matches, is India's leading wicket-taker in the current World Test Championship cycle.

Former India coach Ravi Shastri asked on air where Siraj was, according to The Times of India and The Indian Express, and Sunil Gavaskar called the omission baffling, as reported by Deccan Chronicle and Hindustan Times. Former captain Mohammad Azharuddin said Siraj deserved better consideration, and R Ashwin took a cheeky dig at the call as the "new normal".

India's batting coach Sitanshu Kotak was sent to face the media. He defended the choice, saying he did not personally think it was a wrong decision and that there was nothing wrong with Siraj. He explained that the team wanted height and bounce, two seamers and two swing bowlers on a damp pitch, and that a team picks an XI for four or five days, not one. On Washington over Jadeja, he cited four left-handers in the top order and the chance that Washington would be needed in the second innings. The Hindu reported that seven of the 12 questions at the press conference were about Siraj and Jadeja.

Why it matters

India enter the series with World Test Championship hopes on the line. An early deficit will put pressure on the batting, where the team management has said it values depth, and on a captain who is still early in his tenure. A first-innings total of 350 or more for New Zealand would make life harder for India. The over rate is another watch point: bowling coach Morne Morkel has said the team must keep an eye on the clock to avoid penalties.

What next

Day 2 starts on Friday, 20 November, with Nicholls and Phillips resuming. India will want the new ball, or the old one swinging, to clean up the tail quickly and then bat in a way that shows the extra batting depth was worth the selection call. Whether the Day 1 questions stay on Siraj or move on to the batting will depend on how India's innings begins.